Tuesday, September 13, 2011

Writing to Learn & Chapter 8

I found this article to be very intriguing.  Most grade levels focus in on learning to write, not writing to learn.  However, Knipper and Duggan promoted writing to learn in their article.  Basically, if a student understands a subject well enough to compose a well-written essay about it, he/she will have a better understanding of the content. Students can even begin writing before they read the material.  They can make predictions, form hypotheses, and ask questions in written form which uses strategies in beginning to write to learn.  I agree that teacher feedback is extremely imperative when students are growing in their writing skills. Students need to have an idea of what they are expected to learn from their writing.  Chapter 8 in our textbook discusses the process of writing - prewriting, drafting, peer review, revising, editing, final draft, and publication.  Sure students need to know how to get from prewriting to publication, but using all seven of those steps every time a student writes something can get a little tedious.  I did like how chapter 8 broke down the three main types of knowledge in writing; declarative, procedural, and conditional.  Students need to know what type of learning they are looking for when they begin their writing.  Are they wanting to write out directions to build something or are they explaining how something works? Writing to learn allows students to demonstrate and prove to themselves that they know what they are writing about.

2 comments:

  1. I like your thoughts on writing to learn and how this can prove that students comprehend the material. I also like your ideas on students making predictions before they begin their reading. I think you did a good job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Ashlyn, I'm especially intrigued by this part of your post, "Basically, if a student understands a subject well enough to compose a well-written essay about it, he/she will have a better understanding of the content." Why do you think students have a better understanding if they can write about it? Better than if they could stand up and talk about it? Just curious, found myself wanting more about this. Many people mentioned that writing "proves" understanding. But if talking about it can do the same, why write?

    Liked how you honed in on prewriting, "Students can even begin writing before they read the material. They can make predictions, form hypotheses, and ask questions in written form which uses strategies in beginning to write to learn."

    And most imp for me to read, which is very much why I'm writing this very response, is your comment, "I agree that teacher feedback is extremely imperative when students are growing in their writing skills. Students need to have an idea of what they are expected to learn from their writing." You pushed me to think about what you, as students in 411, think about writing blog responses, especially if you think writing shows understanding. It's the feedback from me and peers (and giving feedback) that makes this weekly process come alive.

    One last comment, give me a little more in your posting. You make some great comments, but show me you can bite off a bigger chunk of the reading and respond with more depth. Dr B

    ReplyDelete